The bogeyman of authoritarianism...

This quote is from the Reformed World article I've posted here on Baylyblog which gives the history of the ordination of woman officers within Reformed denominations around the world.

The article's author is absolutely certain woman officers in the church is a good thing, but she realizes many still consider it a weakness that women don't have the natural weight of authority a man has. Her solution?

A Reformed congregation for whom the priesthood of all believers is an article of faith should not consider it a disqualification that a woman pastor is not and has no desire to be the traditional authoritarian stereotype, but rather as an opportunity held out to it.

To which an older Presbyterian pastor with many years of pastoral ministry behind him responded to me privately... (he gave me permission to post this):

I bought into this completely--not as applying especially to women, but as a "democrat," I guess. Not until very late in my service as a pastor did the question of whether and what authority a pastor has trouble me. I now--living within a pastorless situation--have begun--only begun--to realize that not recognizing the existence & function of pastoral authority both corrupted and crippled my ministry.

So sad. So wise. Learn from this, husband whom God has given responsibility for your wife, father and mother whom God has given responsibility for your sons and daughters. Take this to heart, pastors and elders and deacons whom God has given responsibility for your sheep.

Comments

We act as if authority were something we invented, as if it is completely our option whether to use it or not, rather than something that belongs to God and that He has entrusted to us and instructed us to use for the good of those He's placed in our care.  If we bury it (and are deaf to the cries of those around us who should have been helped if we used the power we were given), what will we say to our Master on that great Day?

So according to the article's author, if you affirm the priesthood of all believers, then you should welcome the opportunity of ordaining a pastor that defies the "traditional authoritarian stereotype"?

Forget all this talk of ordaining women; that's already becoming boring. If we want to defy authoritarian stereotypes, why not ordain children? After all, didn't Jesus say that the faith of a child was the greatest of all? Instead of being men and defending the weak, we can have children go and fight our Crusades for us. Because that's never been done before, right?

Sarcastically,

Bravo, Elliott!

I just want to know whoever gave her the idea that "the priesthood of all believers" is NOT an "article of faith" for ALL Christians?

The priesthood of all believers has nothing to do with equality.  It means that every Christian has direct access to God by prayer without the need for a priest to intercede.  It has no implications for becoming a priestess.

When you mix "the priesthood of all believers," a doctrine from Martin Luther (circa 1520s);

The pill, a doctrine from Margaret Sanger (circa 1960s);

And award an MDiv to men and women, a doctrine of independent, third-party Reformed seminaries (circa 2000s) ...

... into a cauldron: What will emerge through the boil and bubble?

The Reformed female preacher.

What's the impenetrable bulwark stopping this army of Reformed women from entering the pulpit, especially as co-pastors?

And heaven forbid you should actually *exercise* some authority and discipline in your church!  If you do you will be rewarded with your "victim" opening up her own blog detailing the emotional and spiritual abuse she suffered at your legalistic and authoritarian hands.

It only surprises me a little how indignant some feminists get when an orthodox church body and her shepherds act as if they really do believe what they confess.

How many of those Reformed female preachers you are talking about, are single?

Add new comment