Broad is the road that leads to death...
One of the things contributing to the effeminacy of much of our musical worship is the absence of the Biblical themes of warning and judgment. Yet these were frequent themes in previous centuries when men were more careful to read passages of Scripture that spoke of judgment and to preach for faith and repentance. In my observation, the absence of these themes is as common in high classical Presbyterian worship as it is in Reformed worship of a more contemporary culture.
This is one of the gifts of Clearnote Bloomington's musicians to their pastors and congregation. They are careful to sing of both grace and judgment, faith and repentance. Here was their musical offering during Lord's Day worship yesterday. (TB, w/thanks to Phil; click through to the YouTube page for the words)




Comments
I remember when I had responsibility for selecting hymns at an Evangelical Free Church I got some strange looks for selecting "The Son of God Goes Forth to War." And a short time later the position was abolished with the pastor taking responsibility for the hymns.
"The fearful soul that tires and faints,
And walks the ways of God no more,
Is but esteemed almost a saint,
And makes his own destruction sure."
What a horrible spectre, that I could be a hypocrite and deceived, thinking I'm fine, "almost a saint" -- and miss the way. O Lord, give me that true faith that perseveres.
Not only that, but to sing about anything uncomfortable seems an anathema today - Am I a soldier of the cross, a follower of the lamb? And shall I fear to own His cause or blush to speak His name? Must I be carrier to the skies on flowery beds of ease while others fight to win the prize and sail through bloody seas? Are there no foes for me to face? Must I not stem the flood? Is this vile world a friend to grace to help me on to God? Since I must fight if I would reign increase my courage Lord. I'll bear the toil, endure the pain, supported by Thy Word - Watts
An abiding benefit of hymns is that we sing them repeatedly. We Anglicans reap the same benefits in the prayers that are repeated each Sunday during the Prayers of the People, which contain petitions, praises, and thanksgivings that ought always to be made in every place at all times.
Some months ago, in connection with a homily which had as an application an exhortation to commit evil deeds and evil men to the righteous judgment of God, I noticed that our weekly set prayers contained nothing of this sort, other than what might be considered implicit in the prayer for those in trouble, sorrow, need, sickness, or any other adversity.
Consequently, from that Sunday ever since, after that general prayer for those facing various trials and needs, we pray this:
Lay Reader: Almighty God, who hast promised to put all enemies of your Anointed One under His feet, render unto evil and wicked men who persecute your Son and the members of His body the judgment that is right for their evil and wicked deeds. [Especially do we pray for ...]. Comfort and save those who suffer for the sake of Jesus and deliver them out of the hand of their enemies. Lord in your mercy,...
Congregation: Hear our prayer.
Love it. It reminds me in genre of a group of "shape note" singers we had in our town last summer, with a hint of chant.
My kids love a little spoof I've made of too much modern, and too much ancient music;
"I have a song that someone gave me
It was sent from who knows where
and it's a good thing it was sent for free
for for a tune they did not care, cause
....in that song there is no melody
there is no melody, and not a harmony
in that song there is no melody,
there is no melody to sing...."
It only gets worse from there. My apologies.
I ought also to have mentioned a special prayer service, rarely done these days, called "A Commination or Denouncing of God's Anger and Judgements against Sinners" which was customarily done on Ash Wednesday (forming the service for that day before the imposition of ashes), and at other times as the bishop might direct.
It is an edifying and instructive service to pray, particularly as it should be done -- by a congregation led by its elder(s). The text from the 1662 BCP may be found here:
http://www.eskimo.com/~lhowell/bcp1662/occasion/commination.html
His Majesty's Clerkes... Goostly Psalmes... love it!
Thank you, Phil and Clearnote Choir!
Love,
Brian
"One of the things contributing to the effeminacy of much of. . "
What makes a song feminine? That it's pleasant? And why is that bad, exactly?
CRS,
Please notice that Tim did not say, "One of the things contributing to the femininity of much of our musical worship...", but rather "effeminacy". Effeminacy does not equal femininity. Femininity is a good thing. Furthermore, Tim's statement was not in reference to this or that particular song, but rather to the general state of worship music in the church today.
Effeminacy occurs when the feminine aspects of worship dominate the masculine, whereas it should be the other way around. One way this manifests itself is when we have scads of songs about God as our lover and friend and none about God as our Lord, Captain, and Judge, who leads us into battle and avenges the blood of the saints.
We sang "The Son of God Goes Forth to War" at the end of this very service.
y'all need to sing some shapes! Go find a sacred harp or christian harmony singing in your area- fasola.org. It's a great opportunity for witness- many believers sing, but so do many secular hobbyists. You will love the raw, unfettered worship of the singing, the rough-hewn power of it, and the texts by Isaac Watts and so many others that speak clearly of the judgement, power, wrath and love of our almighty God.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mJE2tAC0cbA&feature=relmfu
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Dz7hOWvJHU&feature=related
I second Brian's thank you to the choir and to Phil for leading. My mom who visited this weekend really enjoyed the choir, and loves the Christmas CD. But I can remember at the Evangelical Free church I attended back in Cincinnati, one Sunday, the Pastor led us in, Onward Christian Soldier, and everyone just kind of stopped afterward and talked about how great that was to reminisce of songs of that nature. I kept thinking we should do this every sunday, but then they went right back to the regular routine of what was mostly man centered, personal songs. It was almost like the light was finally breaking through, but then it got dimmed again, because it shouldn't be too bright, it may cause a scene.
CRS; quick note. Feminine is great. Effeminacy is the cringe-inducing attempt of a man to model femininity. It doesn't look the same all the time--manly men of many ages have worn pink well, for example--but in general, effeminacy is the male abdication of male roles (father, leader, pastor) in favor of female roles (nurturer, mother, etc..).
So if you've got a pattern of emphasizing female roles to the exclusion of male roles in church--music singing only of the woman's perspective, sermons ignoring God's Fatherhood, and such--you have basically emasculated the church and made it effeminate. And then people who do so wonder why the men aren't there--at least not men worth giving a ring to.
Thanks, Bert.
I don't see why being a nurturer is feminine, though. Most fathers are (or should be) quite nurturing. Nurturing is a role held by both sexes.
Actually, it sounds pretty effeminate to worry about whether your songs are masculine or not. Men who are secure in their masculinity sing whatever brings them closer to God. How silly to say "rough and tough"= masculine. Mankind is far more complicated than that.
"And then people who do so wonder why the men aren't there--at least not men worth giving a ring to."
Also, I don't think you should choose your hymns based on what will increase attendance.
"Effeminacy occurs when the feminine aspects of worship".
I am confused. What exactly is effeminacy, what is considered the feminine aspects of worship and what is considered the masculine aspects of worship? Can there be a balance between the two? I have no idea whether the church I attend is effeminite or masculine. We sing hymns, all the leaders are male, the preaching is expository and the church is involved with the community. All of the churhes I have ever attended are like that, so to me that is normal. I have never given any thought to whether any one of them were feminine or masculine and that is why I am confused and asking.
LP,
Two recent posts, one by Doug Wilson and the other by myself, should go a long way to answering your questions...
http://www.dougwils.com/Liturgical-Notes/your-worship-service-might-be-effeminate-if.html#JOSC_TOP
http://www.baylyblog.com/2011/08/masculine-worship-thrashing-guitars-and-lots-of-dm.html
Blessings,
CRS,
It's not surprising that a man who shoots from the shadows does not embrace God's order of creation or the Biblical exercise of discernment. Anonymity in a fight is passive-aggressive. And passive-aggressiveness is indicative of a deep commitment to effeminacy. If you want to be taken seriously as an authority on masculinity, try starting with your real name.
Sincerely,
Jody Killingsworth
Jody,
Hello, are you male or female?
I don't want to be taken as an authority on masculinity, I was just stating an opinion.
CRS
>Hello, are you male or female?
In light of your comments, what difference does it make?
>I don't want to be taken as an authority on masculinity, I was just stating an opinion.
More passive-aggression.
Wonderful song. In addition to Goostly Psalmes, curious ones should check out "Rivers of Delight" — by the Word of Mouth Chorus—an old (ca. 1979) collection of sacred harp/shapenote songs (available in iTunes). Includes Windham and many others.
One note on the musical genre which might enflame the comments on effeminacy: in these songs the melody is usually sung by the tenor section, not the soprano as we have become accustomed to. Wonderful concept: men leading singing!
And you can visit www.fasola.org for a good overview of the genre.
For the record, "Chris" is from the same city where we've had a liar posting under a number of different names for quite some time, now. I have to work hard to keep up with him (her). Likely this is the same person under a new name since we have no other comments coming from this city.
Thanks to those who have worked to answer the good questions.
Love,
Add new comment