False dichotomies and contemporary worship music....
(Tim: this from our worship minister and music director, Jody Killingsworth) Defenders of traditional worship consistently present a false dichotomy. Observing that CCM is lyrically and theologically impoverished, they conclude that this must somehow be the fault of the music. As if popular style and lyrical drivel are somehow intrinsically connected. Bring in the drums and guitars, they say, and inevitably you'll have us singing 30-minute versions of “Shine Jesus, Shine” every Sunday.
I’m sympathetic, of course, because CCM really is the mountain of emotive garbage they say it is, and there are precious few positive examples to point to. But this isn’t the fault of the rock n’ roll genre, per se. Rather, it highlights the failure on the part of godly pastors and elders to lead musicians to think...
Here at ClearNote we’re fighting to protect both the lyrical integrity of the Church’s song, and to promote its cultural relevance. We believe these two categories are not mutually antithetical, but form the necessary ingredients of all true reform.
Our latest batch of worship songs now available for free download provides listeners a glimpse of our vision for reforming Christian worship. We sing these songs in our services pretty much as you hear them on the album (just add congregation). There are old texts here with old tunes, there are old texts with new tunes, and there are new texts with new tunes. If you like what we’re doing but object to the fact we haven’t included any Psalm settings, be patient. We’re getting there. Remember, Rome wasn’t built in a day.




Comments
I was worried that there weren't any comments, but I guess everyone's too busy listening to the new album!
I was thinking about this just yesterday--and the way I'd have phrased it (and did to my wife) is that it's not the instrumentation or rhythms used, but rather whether the poetry/lyrics is any good, and then whether the music works with, or against, the poetry.
I'll take a listen....
Jody - I'll concur, with a small note that I'm sure you've already thought of in some context: you face the same challenge as Christian authors, that whatever you write in the next several years has to compete against the very best of 3500 years of writing. It makes sense that most writing or music from a generation will be drivel, because most writing or music from *all* generations will be drivel. The great stuff (along with some detritus) will be passed along, the rest forgotten.
Add new comment