Court jousters...
(Tim, w/thanks to David G.) In the particular denomination calling itself the Presbyterian Church in America, here's what it's all come down to. WWTD.
This as reported by the PCA's monthly promo magazine, byFaith:
[Tall Steeple Pastor Number One] emphasizes the need to find and celebrate shared animating values within the denomination. But this shift will need to come from the top, he says.
Leadership has to cultivate a sense of what these animating values are, and that will involve risk. We will have to celebrate things in common that will disappoint those within our own animating values culture.” But, he says, this will lead to greater denominational unity and mission, better communication, and ultimately greater joy, enabling us to “give each other joy in ministry—not just survive each other.”
As an example, [Tall Steeple Pastor Number One] describes the growing friendship between himself--self-described as gravitating toward a traditional church model and “the ordinary means of grace”--and [Tall Steeple Pastor Number Two] who is known for his bent toward contextualization and cultural engagement. (In recent years, [Tall Steeple Pastors Numbers One and Two] have frequently spoken from different points of view at denominational forums on topics ranging from women’s roles to the direction of the PCA.)
“Just by interacting with [Tall Steeple Pastor Number Two], I’ve learned how much theologically we have in common, and I’ve learned to see my own blind spots and compensate for them,” said [Tall Steeple Pastor Number One].
These days, [Tall Steeple Pastor Number One] says, when thinking over a theological or ministry issue, he tends to ask himself: “If I said this to [Tall Steeple Pastor Number Two], how would he respond?”
Yes, yes; the world's been waiting for covert evangelism. Overt is, like, totally passé. Then too, check out those things he calls "values."
"The shifts ...need to come from the top, he says." What could make us feel more secure than [Tall Steeple Pastor Number One's] men at "the top" defining and helping our core values to ambulate? Think of the Supreme Court. Think of the Senate and House of Representatives. Think of the White House. It's up at the "top" where tall steeple pastors reside that "things need to come from" before we'll get "joy."
Really?
Trust me. It won't be the rich and famous who reform the Church.




Comments
" It won't be the rich and famous who reform the Church"
Has that *ever* been the case?
Josiah.
Also John XXIII. ;-\
Love,
Tim,
National Review's cantankerous columnist John Derbyshire often laments that the world has become so absurd that effective parodies are impossible. The absurdity of the parody does not stand out against the absurdity of reality -- a real loss for humor.
If there were The Onion for ByFaith this passage could run unedited.
Love,
David
Tim, good observations.
The difference, though, between the senate, house of reps, and supreme court, is that, technically speaking, we have no "top." Even the SJC is simply chosen to act in the name of the governing body, which is the GA.
The only "top" in Presbyterianism is the General Assembly. I wonder if we really think that this is the source of Reformation. A friendship between Keller and Duncan sounds more like bottom up.
According to byFaith, Duncan said that this change must come from the "top." I wonder what Duncan actually said. This seems like a strange way for someone devoted to classic Presbyterianism to speak.
I never realized that I was part of an Animating Values Culture. Gosh.
Well, good for Duncan.
"Never let us be guilty of sacrificing any portion of truth on the altar of peace." ~ J.C. Ryle
At my work (I am a public employee), we hear a lot of management buzzwords ("paradign shift", "moving forward" "reframing" etc). Our attitude to them is very sceptical, and we let our senior managers know it.
Now I see this sort of 'buzzword culture' infesting the church. It's nonsense, to substitute these sort of meaingless words for hard thinking as to where the PCA, never mind the wider church, should be going.
Wes - I apologize if I am missing or misreading your point, but reading your comment straight, while it is technically true that the PCA doesn't have an official "top", I will say that while attending a large PCA church in Texas (fairly far from the inner workings of the PCA), I've been surprised at the veneration of Pastor Keller, and of how some of the elders will follow something akin to "party lines" while voting at GA. This is purely anecdotal, but there it is, and it is concerning to me. The idea of "top down" leadership has been so disastrous and worldly in historical Christianity to make me think it can be called contra-Christ.
This sort of speak is so sickening, and as far as I can see it's in the bloodstream of the PCA which does not bode well for her health.
Add new comment