Here's an E-mail just received from my dear friend, John Archibold, who has given me permission to put it up on the blog. John had read the recent post, Mainline sodomites and evangelical feminists: Who really loves Jesus?, and this is his response. But first, who is John Archibold?
Back in 1979-80, Mary Lee and I spent a year in Boulder, Colorado, where I had been hired to serve a one-year pastoral internship at First Presbyterian Church prior to entering Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary in the Fall of 1980. During that year, Dad put us in touch with John and Molly Archibold, old friends from Inter-Varsity Christian Fellowship days, and the Archibolds graciously invited us to their Denver home for dinner one evening.
We had never met the Archibolds, but that evening meal and the conversation that followed late into the night remains one of the most memorable and influential contacts in Mary Lee's and my life. At the time, the Archibolds were members of their local Episcopal parish. Later, they left the Episcopalians for the Anglican Catholics--a way-station on the way to Rome, I thought at the time. Then, sure enough, they converted to what I call Roman Catholicism and they call Catholicism. They love Rome and all she stands for, and I think they're wrong. Woefully so, given the stark difference between the Roman Catholic doctrine and practice of justification, particularly the distinction between the infusion and imputation of Christ's righteousness.
But I'm not writing this to fight that battle, at the moment. Rather, to pay tribute to John and Molly for all they've meant in my life and that of my family, and also to demonstrate that there is a Roman Catholic who loves me and is convinced that I, like many other reformed pastors before me, will soon enter Rome. What can I say?
Well, loving John as I do, I'd suggest he not hold his breath. Here's his loving letter...
You're getting close, but you're not quite there yet--but I predict you will be. It does not surprise me that evangelicals are crumbling, too.
You are tough minded and a straight thinker. So let me give it to you straight--the only entity in the world concerning which the Lord said the gates of hell would not prevail against it is the Catholic Church. Everything else (and I literally mean everything else--nations, kingdoms, empires, Protestantism in all of its forms, Orthodoxy, Anglicanism, General Motors, communism, fascism, capitalism, democracy, Microsoft, [you can keep going]) is temporary.
That the gates of hell will not prevail against the Catholic Church does not mean that they (the gates of hell in all of its forms within, without, below, above) won't try. They have, are doing so now, and will continue to do so.
Sooner or later, you will be in the Catholic Church--with its warts and all. It is inevitable. Meanwhile, I share your frustrations and sadness at how many so-called evangelicals fail to understand true (not phony "compassionate" love)--a failing of many Catholic pastors and bishops as well. Don't let family ties hold you back.
My late grandfather was one of the founders and First Vice President of the Colorado Bar Association, of which I have been a member for over 46 years. The Board of Governors of the Colorado Bar Association recently passed resolutions supporting same-sex benefits and opposing the Colorado marriage initiative [ie, marriage is between one man and one woman] which hopefully will be on the ballot this November. So I am outta there--and I have so informed the leadership. (The Colorado Bar Association, regretfully, is no longer a professional association of attorneys, but it has morphed into being just another special interest political action group for the Colorado Democratic Party and its anti-life and socially destructive policies.)
Molly and I will have been members of the Catholic Church for 11 years next January--wouldn't trade it for the world.